When macOS Reduce Motion is enabled, Relaunch uses a fade rather than the decorative opening style you selected. The Motion card explains that override. An unchanged-looking fade does not necessarily mean a zoom or rise preference failed to save.
Treat readability as a separate task
Make names visible and choose an icon size that is comfortable on the actual display. If the page feels crowded, reduce rows or columns instead of depending on a transition to communicate where each app went.
A simple color or quieter background can make labels easier to distinguish. Compare a folder as well as the first page so the setup remains usable where the library is denser.
Keep stable input routes
A keyboard shortcut and arrow-based navigation can make the opening and choosing sequence repeatable. A layout with familiar positions provides context without requiring every interaction to have a large visual movement. Choose the routes that fit your needs rather than enabling all gestures at once.
Test the whole repeated sequence
Open the grid from a normal app.
Select an app or enter a folder.
Back out with Escape.
Repeat with your normal motion and accessibility preferences still enabled.